Penalty Shootout Rules: Complete Guide

Birth of the Penalty Shootout

Before 1970, drawn knockout matches were decided by a coin toss or a replay. The concept of a single match that must produce a winner — and the nerve-shredding drama of the penalty shootout — did not exist. The problem became acute in the 1968 European Championship, when the semi-final between Italy and the Soviet Union was decided by a coin toss. Italy won the toss, advanced to the final, and won the tournament. The Soviet Union went home without kicking a ball in a tiebreaker.

IFAB took action in 1970, approving the "kicks from the penalty mark" system as a method of determining a winner. The first competitive shootout took place on 5 August 1970 in the Watney Cup, a pre-season English tournament. Manchester United defeated Hull City in the shootout after a 1-1 draw. Denis Law scored the first ever shootout penalty, and United won 4-3. The shootout was considered a curiosity rather than a serious addition to the game.

The first major tournament shootout came in the 1976 European Championship final, when Czechoslovakia defeated West Germany 5-3 on penalties after a 2-2 draw. Antonin Panenka's famous chipped penalty — the "Panenka" — decided the shootout. Panenka feigned a powerful shot, sending West German goalkeeper Sepp Maier diving to his right, before chipping the ball gently down the centre. The technique became one of the most iconic in football, though Panenka later admitted he had never practised it before the final.

The 1978 World Cup was the first to use penalty shootouts. The first shootout in World Cup history came in the group stage — technically impossible in modern formats — when Tunisia drew 0-0 with West Germany but needed a shootout to determine group placement. The first World Cup knockout shootout came in 1982, when West Germany defeated France 5-4 in the semi-final after a 3-3 draw.

The Rules Explained

The penalty shootout procedure is governed by IFAB's Laws of the Game. At the end of extra time, the referee conducts a coin toss to determine which end of the field the shootout will take place and which team kicks first. The winning captain chooses either the order of kicks or the end; the losing captain gets the remaining choice.

The goalkeeper from the team that kicked first stands at one end; the goalkeeper from the second team waits at the halfway line with their teammates. All eligible players — those on the field at the end of extra time — must be in the centre circle. Only the kicker and the opposing goalkeeper may be in the penalty area during each kick.

Each team takes five penalties alternately. The ball is placed on the penalty spot, 11 metres from the goal line. The goalkeeper must remain on the goal line, facing the kicker, until the ball is kicked. The goalkeeper may move laterally along the line but cannot come off it. The kicker may not feint at the point of kicking — the stutter-step run-up is permitted, but the actual kicking motion must be continuous.

If the score is level after five penalties each, the shootout enters sudden death. Each team takes one penalty alternately until one scores and the other misses. Any eligible player can take the sudden death penalties, including players who have already taken one. The goalkeeper may take a penalty — a rare but not unknown occurrence.

The shootout ends immediately when the result is determined. If Team A scores their fifth penalty to go 4-3 up, and Team B has only taken four penalties, the shootout ends — Team A wins 4-3. Team B does not need to take their fifth penalty because the result is mathematically determined.

The ABBA Experiment

The traditional alternating order (ABABAB) gives the team that kicks first a statistical advantage. Research by academics at the London School of Economics found that the team kicking first wins approximately 60% of shootouts. The advantage is attributed to psychological pressure: the team kicking second is always under more pressure because they are constantly catching up.

In 2017, UEFA trialled the ABBA system, inspired by tennis tie-breaks. Under the ABBA system, the order was: Team A kicks first, Team B kicks second, Team B kicks third, Team A kicks fourth, then Team A again for the fifth, Team B for the sixth — essentially alternating the pressure of going first across both teams.

The system was used in UEFA youth competitions and the UEFA Women's Under-17 Championship. The results were mixed. Players and coaches reported confusion about the order, and broadcasters struggled to explain the system to viewers. The ABBA system was abandoned after the 2017-18 season, with UEFA and IFAB concluding that the traditional alternating system, despite its statistical bias, was simpler and more familiar.

The ABBA experiment highlighted the broader debate about the fairness of penalty shootouts. Critics argue that the shootout is a poor way to decide a football match, favouring luck and psychological resilience over football skill. Proponents counter that the shootout is a test of nerve and technique and that its drama is an integral part of football's appeal.

Psychology of Penalties

The penalty shootout is as much a psychological battle as a technical one. The pressure of taking a penalty in a shootout — with the match outcome resting on a single kick — is unlike anything else in football. Studies have shown that the success rate in shootout penalties (approximately 75%) is significantly lower than in-match penalties (approximately 82%), confirming the psychological dimension.

The goalkeeper's role in the psychological battle is crucial. Goalkeepers employ various tactics to unsettle the kicker: delaying the penalty, moving slowly to their position, stretching ostentatiously, and making exaggerated gestures. The "psych-out" is a legitimate part of the goalkeeper's armoury. Bruce Grobbelaar's "spaghetti legs" antics in the 1984 European Cup final — wobbling his knees and smiling at the kicker — are the most famous example of goalkeeper psychology.

The penalty run-up reveals much about the kicker's state of mind. A confident kicker typically takes a short, quick run-up; a nervous kicker may pause, stutter, or change their approach. The risk of the stutter-step is that it can lead to a blocked penalty if the goalkeeper delays their dive. The 2022 World Cup final saw Emiliano Martinez use a combination of psychological tactics — delaying penalties, engaging with the crowd, and dancing on the goal line — to unsettle French kickers.

The "saveable penalty" concept has become a key part of modern goalkeeping. Goalkeepers are trained to focus on penalties in the "middle third" of the goal — the area between hip and shoulder height where the goalkeeper has the best chance of making a save. By contrast, penalties placed in the bottom corners are virtually unsaveable if placed correctly. The goalkeeper's challenge is to guess the correct direction and hope the penalty is not perfectly placed.

Most Famous Shootouts

Italy vs France in the 2006 World Cup final was the most dramatic shootout in World Cup history. After Zinedine Zidane's infamous headbutt in extra time, Italy won 5-3 on penalties. Fabio Grosso scored the decisive penalty, sparking joyous celebrations. The shootout was notable for the pressure — the World Cup final, the absence of Zidane, and the weight of football history.

Brazil vs Italy in the 1994 World Cup final was the first to be decided on penalties. The match finished 0-0 after 120 minutes, a cagey, tense affair that reflected the defensive strengths of both teams. Brazil won 3-2 on penalties, with Roberto Baggio — the Italian talisman — blasting his decisive penalty over the crossbar. The image of Baggio standing with his hands on his hips, head bowed, became one of the World Cup's most poignant moments.

England vs West Germany in the 1990 World Cup semi-final was a watershed moment for English football. England lost 4-3 on penalties, with Stuart Pearce and Chris Waddle missing. The shootout introduced English fans to the unique agony of penalty defeat — an experience that would be repeated in 1996, 1998, 2004, 2006, and 2012. The 1990 shootout changed English football's relationship with penalties, creating a psychological burden that lasted for decades.

Liverpool vs AC Milan in the 2005 Champions League final — the Miracle of Istanbul — was decided on penalties after Liverpool's extraordinary 3-3 comeback. Jerzy Dudek's double save against Andriy Shevchenko in the dying minutes of extra time preserved the draw, and his "spaghetti legs" impression on the goal line — copying Bruce Grobbelaar's 1984 routine — unsettled Milan's kickers. Liverpool won 3-2 on penalties, with Dudek saving penalties from Andrea Pirlo and Shevchenko.

Chelsea vs Bayern Munich in the 2012 Champions League final was the most dramatic shootout of the modern era. Bayern Munich were playing at home, in their own stadium, and had dominated the match. Chelsea, reduced to 10 men after Didier Drogba's red card in the 88th minute, held on for extra time. The shootout saw Chelsea win 4-3, with Didier Drogba scoring the decisive penalty. The image of Drogba's celebration — running across the pitch, arms spread wide — captured the raw emotion of the moment.

Goalkeeper Heroes

Sepp Maier, the West German goalkeeper, was a pioneer of penalty shootout psychology. His relaxed, almost casual demeanour on the goal line unsettled kickers. Maier's performance in the 1976 European Championship final — saving two penalties but still losing to Panenka's chip — demonstrated the fine margins of shootout success.

Sergio Goycochea of Argentina became a national hero in the 1990 World Cup. The reserve goalkeeper started the tournament as backup to Nery Pumpido, but when Pumpido was injured in the group stage, Goycochea took over. He saved penalties in Argentina's quarter-final shootout against Yugoslavia (two saves) and the semi-final against Italy (two saves). Argentina reached the final, though Goycochea could not prevent Germany's victory.

Dino Zoff, Italy's legendary goalkeeper, saved a crucial penalty in the 1982 World Cup semi-final shootout against Brazil. Zoff, who was 40 years old at the time, used his experience and positioning to guide Italy to victory. His leadership in the shootout was credited with settling Italy's nerves and securing their place in the final, which they won.

Oliver Kahn, Germany's captain in the 2002 World Cup, was renowned for his intimidating presence in shootouts. Kahn's aggressive style — sprinting off his line, shouting at kickers, and making himself as large as possible — was designed to intimidate. His performance in the 2002 Champions League final, saving three penalties in the shootout against Valencia, was one of the greatest goalkeeping displays in a shootout.

Emiliano Martinez of Argentina became the defining goalkeeper of the 2022 World Cup shootout generation. His performance in the final against France — saving Kingsley Coman's penalty and seeing Aurelien Tchouameni miss — was built on psychological warfare. Martinez delayed every penalty, engaged with the crowd, and taunted French players. His approach was controversial but effective, and he was named the tournament's best goalkeeper.

Shootout Statistics

Penalty shootout conversion rates vary by competition and era. The overall success rate in major tournaments is approximately 75%, meaning one in four penalties is missed. The conversion rate in World Cup shootouts is slightly higher at 76%, while Champions League shootouts convert at approximately 73%.

Germany (including West Germany) has the best shootout record in World Cup history, winning 6 of 7 shootouts. Their only loss came against Germany's own under-21 team — a quirk of Olympic football. Germany's success is attributed to a combination of technical excellence, psychological preparation, and a cultural belief in their ability to win shootouts.

England has the worst World Cup shootout record, winning 1 of 4 shootouts. Their only win came against Colombia in 2018, after decades of penalty heartbreak. England's penalty training was completely overhauled after the 2018 World Cup, with Gareth Southgate introducing an evidence-based approach to selection and preparation. The improvement was evident at the 2022 World Cup, where England won their shootout against France — though the match did not reach penalties.

The most common penalty direction in shootouts is to the goalkeeper's right (the kicker's natural side for right-footed players). Approximately 40% of penalties are struck to the goalkeeper's left, 30% to the right, and 30% down the middle. Goalkeepers dive to their left 42% of the time, to their right 40%, and stay central 18%. The penalty taker's best strategy, statistically, is to strike firmly and accurately to one of the bottom corners — penalties in this area are saved only 10% of the time.

The penalty shootout remains football's most dramatic and controversial tiebreaker. It has produced moments of ecstasy and agony, heroes and villains, and a shared human drama that transcends the sport. Despite calls for reform — the ABBA system, the "alternating spot kick," the elimination of sudden death — the penalty shootout endures. It is imperfect, unpredictable, and occasionally unfair. It is also unforgettable.

Related Content

Explore the World Cup hub for comprehensive competition coverage.

Explore the Premier League hub for comprehensive competition coverage.

Visit the Arsenal team page for detailed squad and performance data.

Visit the Barcelona team page for detailed squad and performance data.

Read our in-depth penalty shootout rules guide article.

Read our in-depth handball rule explanation article.

Learn more with our VAR technology guide.

Learn more with our offside rule guide.

Browse our football guide blueprints for more football content.

Browse our player profile blueprints for more football content.

Discover more football guides.

Discover more match predictions.